(www.fridaysixpm.com/archives/2006_10_01_fridaysixpm_archive.html)
Tuesday, October 03, 2006
Booker Review: Mother's Milk, Edward
St Aubyn
I stayed up last night until I finished this novel -
partly because my visiting mother kept pinching the book to read herself
whenever I put it down, and partly because I was so dazzled by individual
sentences that I really had to concentrate to follow the plot. St Aubyn is a
flamboyantly clever writer who made me giggle over and over, but his subject is
pain: the pain of maternal betrayal, and the pain of watching yourself re-enact
that betrayal in your own relationships.
Much has been made of the
novel's inventive opening, a virtuoso prose passage in which a hyper-aware
five-year-old recalls the experience of his own birth and infancy. The approach
is deliberately non-realistic, but it's not just a gimmick - it works in
beautifully with St Aubyn's depiction of the compression of generations and the
vital developmental importance of a child's early years.
Of course
there were weaknesses - the thinly sketched character of the young mother Mary
is one - but the novel is a work of brilliance. Like Hyland's novel, pain here
is palpable. My heart was wrenched for both Patrick, the young depressed
father, and Robert, his impressionable son. At the same time, like I said, I
was laughing at St Aubyn's devastating turn of phrase: after a long, bitter
interior monologue, "Patrick ditched his little fantasy with a sarcastic
yelp" - that's funny! Intellect is used to craft the novel, but it's never
glorified for its own sake. There's a bit where Patrick observes that he
consists of a strong intellect, a deep sense of loss and need, and nothing in
between - that's sad.
I've decided that I'll metaphorically slap
anyone who doesn't love this book. To see it as somehow flawed because it
wasn't "realistic" (hello reading group reps at the official Man
Booker blog) is to lack either empathy or intelligence. Mother's Milk is
beautiful, thoughtful, and stylish. I'll be pretty happy if this one wins.